Welcome to The Prospect Tavern
The Prospect Tavern, nestled in Madison, NJ, is a beloved neighborhood pub that combines a welcoming atmosphere with a diverse menu of American comfort food. Known for its friendly service, this family-owned establishment offers patrons a chance to enjoy everything from flavorful burgers to delightful vegetarian options. With outdoor seating and live music on select nights, it’s a great spot for groups or a casual family dinner. Notable highlights include their exceptional macaroni and cheese balls and hearty sirloin burgers. The Prospect Tavern embodies community spirit, making each visit feel like a gathering at home. Enjoy their vibrant ambiance alongside mouthwatering dishes.
The Prospect Tavern: Reviews & Ratings
We got there just before they closed and they still happily made us dinner. Bartender was very friendly and attentive.
Service is always outstanding. Carol, the owner, is always there and takes care to make sure all have a great time. We love the neighborhood feel. Sort of like our own Cheers.
My Mom and I enjoyed our first visit to the Prospect Tavern. What a fantastic familyowned business! The owner, her sons, and the staff were incredibly kind and helpful. And the food was AMAZING!!! We enjoyed the potato skins and a ...
I had the New England clam chowder..which was fantastic and a huge flavorful burger. The 7 other people I was with all enjoyed their food as well. Linda the waitress was patient answering questions and made a couple good recommendations. Will definitely be back.
Ive always passed this place when in the area, and I finally had some time to go inside and enjoy an early dinner with my wife. Its a nice pub inside, nothing fancy but it was comfortable and relaxing. We were there during off hours, so ...
You will love this place!! The food is amazing...started with the mac and cheese balls and prime rib jalapenos omg....delicious. I had the ranchero burger which was cooked to a perfect medium rare...soooo good...my wife said the Salmon was amazing. Abby was our server and she was fantastic!!! Love this place!!!
Food is great and very fresh and service was very quick. However, it was really quiet during the day. I guess I like a little more music in the background.
Dont listen to the one star reviews. This place is very warm and great for conversing. Its not so loud like the other bars around the area. The food is amazing and happy hour prices are great and affordable you are in a bar after all ...
Location
-
14 Prospect St, Madison, NJ 07940 Hotline: (973) 295-6255
Welcome to The Prospect Tavern, a gem nestled in the heart of Madison, NJ. This bustling American pub is more than just a place to grab a drink; it embodies a warm, inviting atmosphere that feels like home. With its cozy decor and friendly vibe, it’s like walking into your neighborhood’s beloved hangout spot, reminiscent of those classic 'Cheers' moments.
Located at 14 Prospect St, Madison, NJ 07940, The Prospect Tavern offers a delightful menu with a wide variety of options that cater to every palate. Whether you're in the mood for a casual pizza night or a hearty meal, this tavern delivers. Highlights include:
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza - A zesty favorite priced at just $9.00.
- Lobster Mac & Cheese - Creamy and indulgent at $17.00, crafted with sautéed lobster meat and a crispy topping.
- Citrus Chili Salmon - Flavored with sweet chili sauce and zest for $18.00, perfect for seafood lovers.
- Braised Sunday Ragu - A comforting dish of Angus beef tenders and freshly made pasta at $16.00.
The Prospect Tavern prides itself on being a versatile venue. It takes reservations and offers takeout, making it an ideal choice for family dinners or casual group gatherings. Additionally, with many vegetarian options available and features like outdoor seating and live music on select nights, there’s something for everyone. Families will appreciate the kid-friendly atmosphere, while groups can enjoy the moderate noise level, perfect for engaging conversations.
As Erich Rebenstorf noted in his glowing review, the staff is attentive and welcoming, embodying the essence of great service. Carol, the owner, is often seen engaging with guests, ensuring that everyone feels valued and appreciated. Christina McAleer echoed this sentiment, highlighting the kindness of the staff and the mouthwatering food that kept her and her mother coming back for more.
On busy nights, particularly Tuesdays, Thursdays, and Saturdays, The Prospect Tavern transforms into a lively hotspot with great happy hour specials and opportunities for dancing. For sports enthusiasts, the tavern also boasts multiple TVs for watching your favorite games in a spirited setting.
If you're in search of a casual dining experience in Madison, The Prospect Tavern is certainly worth a visit. With uncompromised quality in both food and service, it’s a place you'll want to return to time and time again. Don’t take our word for it; come and experience the charm and culinary delights for yourself. You won't be disappointed!
For more information or to make a reservation, call (973) 295-6255. Enjoy your visit to The Prospect Tavern, where good food, good company, and great memories are always on the menu.
